High-Isolation MIMO Antenna Based on Ground Radiation Antenna and One-Wavelength Dipole for 5G Applications
Article information
Abstract
In this paper, a MIMO antenna system was designed using two antennas operating in different modes: a ground-radiating antenna based on a half-wavelength structure and a dipole antenna based on a one-wavelength configuration. Due to the distinct operating modes of the two antennas, intrinsic decoupling between the elements is achieved without the need for additional isolation structures. The measured impedance bandwidths of the designed MIMO antenna are 310 MHz and 450 MHz for each element, respectively. The isolation between the two antennas was observed to be below −12 dB across the entire operating bands, and a maximum isolation of −20.2 dB was recorded at the null point. Furthermore, due to the radiation pattern diversity of the two antennas, the envelope correlation coefficient (ECC) remains below 0.1 throughout the bands, indicating excellent diversity performance. These characteristics make the proposed MIMO antenna a strong candidate for 5G applications requiring high isolation and low correlation.
I. Introduction
With the recent advancements in wireless communication technology, mobile devices are increasingly required to support high data rate services such as video streaming, the Internet of Things (IoT), wearable devices, and smart home applications. To accommodate such high data demands, multiple-input multiple- output (MIMO) antennas are essential. However, implementing MIMO antennas in mobile terminals poses significant challenges due to limited ground plane size, restricted antenna space, and the presence of densely integrated circuits—all of which can degrade antenna performance. In particular, the reduced ground area negatively impacts the isolation between antenna elements in a MIMO configuration.
To enhance isolation in mobile MIMO antenna designs, various parasitic elements—such as monopoles [1], dipoles [2], slits [3], slots [4], stubs [5], and strips [6]—have been introduced. However, as mobile devices continue to integrate more functionalities, the ground plane becomes increasingly crowded with circuit components, making it difficult to allocate additional space for antenna optimization. Furthermore, the inclusion of parasitic elements may adversely affect the overall antenna performance [7]. Therefore, there is a growing demand for MIMO antenna configurations that can achieve high isolation through their inherent electromagnetic behavior, without the use of additional isolation structures.
Such intrinsic isolation can be realized by designing antenna elements that operate in distinct current modes and exhibit radiation pattern diversity. For example, if two antenna elements operate in half-wavelength and full-wavelength modes, respectively, the resulting mode disparity promotes low correlation and high isolation between them, enabling effective decoupled operation [8, 9].
Various isolation techniques have been proposed for MIMO antennas. For example, hybrid decoupling using a neutralization line and ground slot [10], self-isolated antenna designs [11], the use of an inductor at the current minimum location or a capacitor at the current maximum location [12], self-decoupling methods based on antenna orthogonality [13], pattern diversity modification [14], and the use of T-type or loop-type decouplers [15] have been reported. In addition, several recent studies have proposed improved self-isolation techniques for 5G mobile MIMO antennas. Examples include a self-isolation approach using an inverted U-strip [16], a self-isolated structure employing I-shaped stubs [17], a design utilizing parasitic elements combined with DGS [18], and a mixed-coupling based self-isolation technique achieved through close-coupling methods [19]. Table 1 summarizes the decoupling methods and their performance. The mode-difference-based technique employed in this work enables a compact design, as the antennas are integrated rather than separated, requiring no additional antenna space. Furthermore, since the proposed MIMO configuration consists of a ground radiation antenna and a dipole, antenna tuning is less complex. The calculated envelope correlation coefficient (ECC) is mainly attributed to the radiation pattern difference induced by the mode difference and the high isolation, resulting in a lower ECC compared with other approaches.
In this paper, we propose a MIMO antenna design based on characteristic mode analysis (CMA), incorporating a ground radiation antenna (Gradiant) operating in the half-wavelength mode and a dipole antenna operating in the full-wavelength mode. The Gradiant is a compact loop-type antenna that utilizes the ground plane as a radiator, similar to a dipole [20, 21]. By leveraging the ground plane for radiation, it maintains high radiation efficiency even in compact devices, making it ideal for mobile terminals. As a result, the proposed design achieves both enhanced radiation performance and inherently high isolation, without requiring additional decoupling components.
II. Antenna Concept
Fig. 1 shows simplified models of a half-wavelength dipole and a one-wavelength dipole antenna, along with their respective current distributions. In general, regions with strong current density tend to exhibit strong H-fields, while areas with weaker current typically correspond to stronger E-fields. For the half-wavelength dipole, denoted as J1, the current is concentrated near the center, resulting in a strong H-field at the middle and strong E-fields at both ends of the antenna. In contrast, the one-wavelength dipole, denoted as J2, also shows strong E-fields at the antenna ends, but unlike the half-wavelength case, the center region exhibits a stronger E-field than H-field, with the H-field peaking on either side of the center. The difference between the two current distributions exhibits an orthogonal characteristic. This orthogonality is preserved in the radiation patterns generated by the respective current distributions, thereby ensuring good isolation between the two antennas as described by Eq. (1):
Furthermore, Fig. 2 presents the results of characteristic mode analysis (CMA) for the two antennas in the proposed MIMO system. For the half-wavelength dipole (Antenna #1), the modal significance indicates that the first mode is excited around 3.5 GHz. In contrast, the one-wavelength dipole (Antenna #2) exhibits its first mode around half of this frequency, while its second mode resonates near 3.5 GHz. These results demonstrate that the two antennas excite different characteristic modes at the operating band. The modal significance curves therefore confirm the orthogonality between the half- and one-wavelength dipoles, supporting the enhanced isolation mechanism described in Fig. 1.
Fig. 3 shows the configurations of the same-dipole and different-dipole cases along with their simulated results. In Fig. 3(a), the separation distance between the two dipoles is kept identical for all configurations to ensure a fair comparison. The simulated S12 results are shown in Fig. 3(b). When two identical dipoles are used (same dipole case), a low isolation of approximately −4 dB is observed. In contrast, when two different dipoles are employed (different dipole case), the isolation significantly improves to −15.88 dB. This result confirms that employing two dipoles operating with different current modes effectively enhances isolation. The distinct modal characteristics reduce mutual coupling between the antenna elements, thereby achieving higher isolation performance.
III. Antenna Design and Simulation results
1. Antenna Design
Fig. 4 shows the proposed MIMO antenna system, which consists of a Gradiant and a one-wavelength dipole. The ground plane size is 75 mm × 150 mm, and it is etched on an FR-4 substrate (εr = 4.4, tan δ = 0.02) with a thickness of 1.2 mm. As shown in Fig. 4(c), Port 1 is connected to the Gradiant (Antenna #1), which is composed of a 5.5 mm × 5 mm slot and a 4.5 mm × 2 mm feeding loop, located 55.5 mm away from the edge of the ground. Capacitors Cr and Cf are connected to the radiator and the feeding loop, respectively, to tune the antenna’s resonant frequency and impedance. As shown in Fig. 4(b), Port 2 is connected to the one-wavelength dipole (Antenna #2). The radiator has a length of 49 mm, and the antenna is fed capacitively through a symmetrical L-shaped structure with dimensions of 3.3 mm (vertical) and 6.6 mm (horizontal), allowing impedance matching. Although the ground size of 75 mm × 150 mm may seem relatively large, it was chosen to reflect a realistic commercial smartphone platform, and it remains comparable to previously reported designs operating at similar frequencies, as listed in Table 1. Moreover, because the proposed design employs a Gradiant, a sufficiently large ground plane was required to ensure that the orthogonality between the half-wavelength and one-wavelength modes is preserved. Hence, a larger ground size was adopted for reliable verification of the modal characteristics. In addition, the proposed antenna system employs lumped elements to independently control the operating modes of each antenna element, enabling the orthogonality between the modes to be maintained. Owing to this feature, even when the ground size is reduced, the modal orthogonality can still be preserved by appropriately tuning the lumped elements, allowing the antenna to maintain high isolation performance. However, due to the characteristics of the Gradiant, where the ground plane itself acts as the primary radiator, if the ground length becomes smaller than approximately half wavelength at 3.5 GHz, the electrical length becomes insufficient to support stable mode formation. Consequently, the radiation efficiency and impedance bandwidth degrade significantly.
2. Simulation Results and Operation Mechanism
Fig. 5 shows the simulated S-parameters of the proposed MIMO antenna. For Antenna #1, series capacitors Cr and Cf, with values of 0.15 pF and 0.21 pF, respectively, were used to tune the resonant frequency and impedance. In mobile antennas, the radiator is strongly coupled to the device ground plane, while the available design volume is highly constrained. Consequently, the antenna performance is susceptible to user-body loading and the surrounding environment. To mitigate these practical effects and reflect realistic operating conditions, a −6 dB reflection coefficient is commonly adopted as the impedance bandwidth criterion in mobile-terminal antenna design. Previous studies on smartphone and compact MIMO antennas, including those listed in Table 1, have likewise employed the −6 dB standard as a practical bandwidth definition, as it corresponds to acceptable radiation efficiency and realistic terminal operating conditions [10–19, 22]. For comparison, both the −6 dB and −10 dB criteria are indicated in Fig. 5. The proposed antenna fully satisfies the −6 dB bandwidth requirement across the entire target frequency band. Therefore, the design is considered highly suitable for mobile- terminal antenna applications. The resulting impedance bandwidth is 240 MHz (3.37–3.61 GHz). In the case of Antenna #2, the resonant frequency and impedance were matched by adjusting the radiator length and employing the L-shaped feeding structure, achieving an impedance bandwidth of 270 MHz (3.34–3.61 GHz). The mutual coupling (S12) remains below −12 dB within the sub-6 GHz band (3.4–3.6 GHz), and exhibits a particularly high isolation of −17.94 dB at 3.5 GHz, where a null point is observed.
Fig. 6 shows the current distributions of the proposed MIMO antenna at 3.5 GHz. As shown in Fig. 6(a), the current on the ground plane corresponds to a half-wavelength mode, while Fig. 6(b) demonstrates that Antenna #2 operates in a one-wavelength mode. Because each antenna forms a distinct current distribution, the resulting H-field and E-field patterns differ significantly. This field diversity contributes to improved isolation and reduced correlation between the two antenna elements. Furthermore, the surface-current distributions at 3.4, 3.5, and 3.6 GHz are nearly identical, indicating that the same dominant characteristic modes are maintained across the entire operating band. As a result, the differences in the electric- and magnetic-field distributions are preserved over the operating frequencies, and the resulting isolation performance is also consistently maintained. Therefore, the current distribution at 3.5 GHz is presented as a representative example, as it sufficiently illustrates the modal behavior and current paths of the proposed antenna.
Simulated current distribution of MIMO antenna at 3.5 GHz: (a) current distribution of Gradiant and (b) current distribution of dipole antenna.
Fig. 7 shows the effect of a ±10% simulated tolerance on the S-parameters. For lumped elements, precision components generally have tolerances of ±1% or ±5%, while low-cost components may vary by up to ±10%. In this study, the maximum tolerance level of the chip components was considered to evaluate the stability of the proposed antenna performance. Fig. 7(a) emulates temperature-induced variations: only Antenna #1 shows a noticeable change in S11 whereas the response of S12 and the mutual coupling S12 remain essentially unchanged. Fig. 7(b) shows a ±10% FR-4 thickness tolerance: small shifts appear in the S-parameters compared with Fig. 7(a), but the overall antenna performance is scarcely affected. From Fig. 7, we conclude that the proposed design is robust against both temperature-related tolerances and fabrication-induced substrate-thickness variations.
IV. Measured Results
Fig. 8 shows the fabricated antenna and the measurement setup for the proposed MIMO antenna. The fabricated antenna is measured with an Agilent 8753ES network analyzer in a 6 m × 3 m × 3 m 3D CTIA (Cellular Telecommunication Industry Association) over-the-air anechoic chamber.
Fabricated antenna and test environment: (a) the fabricated MIMO antenna and (b) test environment of air anechoic chamber.
Fig. 9 shows the measured and simulated S-parameters of the fabricated MIMO antenna. Series capacitors Cr and Cf, with values of 0.15 pF and 0.2 pF, respectively, were used for frequency tuning and impedance matching. The −6 dB impedance bandwidths were measured to be 310 MHz (3.37–3.68 GHz) for Antenna #1 and 450 MHz (3.39–3.84 GHz) for Antenna #2. The isolation between the two antennas remains below −12 dB within the operating frequency band of 3.4 GHz to 3.6 GHz, with a maximum isolation of −20.2 dB observed at 3.5 GHz, where a null point occurs.
Figs. 10–12 show the simulated and measured radiation patterns of the MIMO antennas at 3.5 GHz. The patterns were measured by exciting one antenna while terminating the other with a matched load. At 3.4 GHz, 3.5 GHz, and 3.6 GHz, the maximum gains of Antenna #1 and Antenna #2 are directed toward opposite directions. This opposing orientation of the main lobes indicates that each antenna radiates in a different direction, which enhances the ability to receive uncorrelated signals from different propagation paths. As a result, this characteristic contributes to achieving a low ECC, which is essential for high diversity performance in MIMO systems.
Measured and simulated radiation patterns of the MIMO antenna at 3.4 GHz: (a) simulated radiation patterns of MIMO antenna and (b) measured radiation patterns of MIMO antenna.
Measured and simulated radiation patterns of the MIMO antenna at 3.5 GHz: (a) simulated radiation patterns of MIMO antenna and (b) measured radiation patterns of MIMO antenna.
Measured and simulated radiation patterns of the MIMO antenna at 3.6 GHz: (a) simulated radiation patterns of MIMO antenna and (b) measured radiation patterns of MIMO antenna.
Fig. 13 presents the measured ECC ρe. The ECC was calculated using Eq. (2) over the frequency range of 3.4 GHz to 3.6 GHz. In Eq. (2), the numerator represents the inner product of the two antennas F⃗1(θ, φ), and F⃗1 (θ, φ), which indicates how similar their radiation is, i.e., the degree of similarity between the two antennas. The denominator is the product of the radiated powers of the two antennas, which normalizes the numerator so that the correlation is evaluated independently of magnitude. Therefore, the ECC shows how closely the two antenna patterns resemble each other. A high ECC value means that the antennas have a high degree of similarity, whereas a low ECC value means that the antennas have low similarity. In MIMO antennas, a low ECC is required to achieve multipath diversity gain and to mitigate shadowing effects.
As discussed earlier, the maximum radiation directions of the two antennas are oriented opposite to each other, which contributes to ensuring diversity performance. This is validated by the calculated ECC values, which remain below 0.05 throughout the 3.4 GHz to 3.6 GHz frequency range. This value is significantly lower than the commonly accepted threshold of ρe < 0.5 for mobile applications, confirming that the proposed MIMO antenna exhibits excellent diversity performance.
Fig. 14 shows the radiation efficiency of the proposed MIMO antenna. The radiation efficiency is calculated for each frequency using Eq. (3), where η0 = 377 Ω.
Radiation efficiency is defined as the ratio of the radiated power to the input power. The input power is the sum of the radiated power and the loss power, where the loss power includes conduction loss, dielectric loss, thermal loss, and other associated losses.
Both antennas exhibit a radiation efficiency higher than 35% within the 3.4 GHz to 3.6 GHz frequency range. The average radiation efficiencies within the 3.4–3.6 GHz band were measured to be 49.35% for Antenna #1 and 55.39% for Antenna #2. Both Antenna #1 and Antenna #2 exhibit high radiation efficiency across the 3.4–3.6 GHz frequency range. These results confirm that both antennas in the MIMO system achieve satisfactory radiation efficiency while maintaining good diversity performance.
V. Conclusion
In this paper, a MIMO antenna system was investigated through both simulation and measurement using a ground-radiating antenna and a one-wavelength dipole. Each antenna operates in different modes—half-wavelength and one-wavelength— which enables wide bandwidths of 310 MHz and 450 MHz, respectively, without the need for additional resonators or decouplers. The proposed design also achieves high isolation of -20.2 dB. Due to the distinct current modes, the main radiation directions of the two antennas are oriented oppositely, ensuring strong pattern diversity and resulting in low ECC values that indicate excellent diversity performance. Consequently, the proposed MIMO antenna enhances overall system performance by inherently achieving high isolation and low correlation, while maintaining high individual antenna performance. Therefore, the findings of this paper are expected to provide valuable insights for the design of MIMO antennas in compact devices for 5G applications.
Notes
This work was supported by Shenzhen Science and Tech- nology Foundation under Grant KJZD20230923114804009.
References
Biography
![]()
Hoseung Lee, https://orcid.org/0000-0002-4570-5720 received his B.S. degree in Electronic Engineering from Korea Polytechnic University, Siheung, Republic of Korea, in 2018 and his M.S. degree in Electronics and Computer Engineering from Hanyang University, Seoul, Republic of Korea in 2020. He has been pursuing a Ph.D. at Hanyang University since 2022. His research interests include mobile antenna design.
![]()
Longyue Qu, https://orcid.org/0000-0001-5152-091X received M.S. and Ph.D. degrees in electromagnetics and microwave engineering from Hanyang University, Seoul, Republic of Korea in 2015 and 2018, respectively. He was a post-doctoral researcher at Hanyang University from September 2018 to August 2019, after which he was promoted to assistant research professor. He is a co-founder and CTO of Hanyang Antenna Design Co. Ltd., Shenzhen, China (2019 to 2022). Since 2022, he has been with the School of Electronics and Information Engineering, Harbin Institute of Technology, Shenzhen, China, as an assistant professor. He has authored more than 50 articles and created more than 30 inventions. He is a reviewer for several international journals and conferences. He is also an editorial board member of the International Journal of Sensors, Wireless Communications, and Control. His current research interests include antenna theory and design, metamaterial-based antenna technology, millimeter-wave arrays, and RF circuits. He was a recipient of the Korean Government Scholarship Award and the China Scholarship Council. His research was listed in the Top 100 National R&D Excellence Award in 2015.
![]()
Seokju Wi, https://orcid.org/0009-0003-8546-0435 received his B.S. degree from Chungnam University, Daejeon, South Korea, in 2020, and he started his integrated Ph.D. process in the Department of Electronic Engineering at Hanyang University, Seoul, South Korea. His main research interests are mobile antenna design based on ground characteristic mode analysis.
![]()
Hyeongdong Kim, https://orcid.org/0000-0003-4540-9451 was born in Kwang-ju, Republic of Korea. He received his B.S. and M.S. degrees from Seoul National University in Seoul, Republic of Korea in 1984 and 1986, respectively, and his Ph.D. degree from the University of Texas in Austin in 1992. From May 1992 to February 1993, he was a post-doctoral fellow at the University of Texas in Austin. In 1993, he was a professor in the Department of Electrical and Computer Engineering at Hanyang University in Seoul, Republic of Korea. His current research interests are various antenna theories and designs based on ground characteristic mode analysis, namely, wide-band, high-efficiency, circular polarization, MIMO, and high-sensitivity antennas.
